Milani Ultrafine Liquid Eye Liner, Review

Milani says: Sparkling intense color, long-lasting, waterproof formula.  The ultrafine felt-tip applicator makes it easy to apply a thick or thin line and dries down to a sparkling finish.

When I first saw these, I immediately thought of the MUFE Aqua Liners.  The packaging is identical, same size and color.  The felt tip applicators are pretty much the same, and if there’s a difference my eyes cannot detect it.

I swatched this next to MUFE Aqua Liner #4 and Stila Sparkle Waterproof Liquid Liner in Electric (pics below).  Get this: Exact dupes.  I kid you not!  Same packaging, same applicators, and the formula are the same.  Now, there may be slight difference in the finish if you really study it under a bright light.  However, at first glance when swatched next to each other, they all look the same.  The Milani is also $16 cheaper than the other two.  How cool is that?

This has the same great quality as some higher end liners for a fourth of the price.  It wears for 10 hours (I suspect it would last longer than that, but I didn’t want to sleep in this to really test it’s staying power).  The downside?  This only comes in 4 colors (2 blacks, turquoise, purple, and emerald).  It’s smooth, pigmented, and has a precise felt tip applicator.  I recommend for my liquid liner gals! BONUS: This is a great way to incorporate Pantone’s color of the year into your makeup!

Glitter Rating: 4.5 / 5
(-0.5 for the limited color range)

Where: Drugstores, Milani. Price: $7.49/0.58 oz
For additional pics,

Milani: $7.49   Stila: $22.00

Milani: $7.49   MUFE: $23.00

Where: Drugstores, Milani. Price: $7.49/0.58 oz

What do you think of of these?  What’s your favorite liquid liner?

Drink water. Wear SPF.

DISCLOSURE: This product was purchased for personal use. All opinions are my own.  Click here to read my full disclosure policy.


About Peace Love and Glitter

I believe that everyone has the right to feel pretty.